
Insights from Dr. Amy Dryer, based on the latest episode of REACHing Solutions, a podcast from The REACH Institute.
Deciding whether a child experiencing a mental health crisis needs to go to the emergency room is one of the most difficult decisions a pediatric clinician can face.
It is not just a clinical decision. It is an emotional moment for everyone involved: the child, their family, and the clinician responsible for helping them navigate an uncertain and often frightening situation.
When safety is at stake, clinicians must balance several important considerations. How do you assess the level of risk? How do you maintain a teenager’s trust while making difficult decisions? And how can you help parents feel supported rather than blamed?
In a new episode of REACHing Solutions, pediatrician Dr. Amy Dryer shares practical advice for navigating these difficult conversations, drawing on more than 20 years of experience, including 10 years in the emergency room.
Ask Direct Questions, Without Judgment
One of the most important steps in responding to a mental health crisis is knowing how to ask about suicide.
For some clinicians, bringing up suicidal thoughts can feel uncomfortable. They may worry about how a young person will react or whether asking directly could introduce the idea. But even when a young person is not experiencing suicidal thoughts, being asked can help them feel seen, heard, and supported.
Dr. Dryer addresses this concern, emphasizing that asking about suicidal thoughts does not increase the risk of suicide. She encourages clinicians to approach the conversation directly rather than avoiding the topic. As she explains, “Asking about trauma does not increase the risk. Asking about suicide does not increase the risk. You don’t traumatize someone by asking.”
Creating space for these conversations means approaching questions directly, calmly, and without judgment. Rather than avoiding difficult topics, clinicians can help young people feel that they are safe to speak honestly about what they are experiencing.
Being able to ask these questions is an essential part of recognizing when a young person may need a higher level of care.
Balance Safety With Trust
When a clinician determines that an emergency room evaluation is necessary, communicating that decision to a teenager can be particularly challenging. Adolescents may feel frightened, frustrated, or even betrayed, especially if they worry that sharing their thoughts will mean losing control over what happens next.
Dr. Dryer highlights the importance of maintaining a young person’s trust while remaining firm about their safety. One way to do this is through transparency. She emphasizes the importance of walking adolescents through exactly what to expect when they arrive at the emergency room, explaining each step of the process so they do not leave feeling uncertain about what will happen next.
These two responsibilities are not mutually exclusive. Clinicians can acknowledge a teenager’s feelings, explain why certain steps are necessary, and continue treating them with respect throughout the process.
The goal should be to preserve the relationship, build trust, and create an environment where the child feels comfortable seeking help in the future.
Support Parents, Too
A child’s mental health crisis can be just as overwhelming for parents and caregivers.
Parents may experience fear, confusion, or guilt as they try to understand what is happening and what they should do next. They may also question whether they missed warning signs or could have done something differently to prevent the situation.
Dr. Dryer emphasizes the importance of reassuring parents that “this is not your fault.”
That reassurance matters. Clinicians play an important role in helping families understand that a mental health crisis is not a reflection of their parenting. Rather than focusing on blame or what could have been done differently, the immediate priority is to help stabilize the child and create a plan to reduce the risk of another crisis.
By approaching caregivers with empathy and without judgment, clinicians can help ease feelings of guilt, reduce stigma, and encourage families to remain engaged in their child’s care.
Be a Steady Partner Through the Crisis
Perhaps the biggest takeaway from Dr. Dryer’s conversation is that supporting a young person through a mental health emergency requires more than making the right clinical decision.
It requires building trust, communicating with compassion, supporting caregivers, and creating systems that help families navigate what comes next.
A crisis can be frightening and uncertain, but pediatric clinicians do not have to have every answer. They can make a difference by being prepared, responding without judgment, and remaining a consistent source of support for young people and their families.
Want to Hear the Full Conversation?
In the full episode of REACHing Solutions, Dr. Dryer dives deeper into:
- How to ask children and adolescents about suicidal thoughts directly and without judgment
- Why asking about suicide does not increase suicide risk
- Balancing adolescent trust and autonomy with the need to prioritize safety
- Supporting parents and caregivers through the emotional impact of a mental health crisis
- Establishing office protocols for responding to pediatric mental health emergencies
- Turning the first post-crisis appointment into an opportunity for ongoing support and safety planning
- Maintaining communication and continuity of care, even when families are difficult to reach
Listen to the full episode of REACHing Solutions to hear Dr. Dryer’s insights and practical advice for navigating pediatric mental health emergencies.
